Owners decide

Public graph

Created about 4 hours ago, updated about 4 hours ago · Owners: Root

ID29512

The rule. A proposal can change several public nodes: edit them, or add nodes and connections under them. Each changed node needs one answer from its owners (see Who owns what): approve, or do not approve and say why. One owner's answer is enough, and the first answer stands. No answer is never a yes.

Where you see it. When a proposal changes your node, it waits for you under Reviewing › Waiting for you, with an action item in For me; You answered keeps the ones you decided. Reviewing shows you nothing else: your own proposals are under Publishing. Only Root sees the whole queue (waiting, back with the writer, decided), with whose answer each proposal waits for, so none is held up. The proposal page shows a Who decides list: each node, its owners, and the answer so far.

Each owner decides for their own node: the approved part is merged, the rest comes back to you
Each owner decides for their own node: the approved part is merged, the rest comes back to you

Your own nodes. If you propose under the handle that owns a node, your change to it is approved by proposing. Under another handle it waits for the other owners, and you cannot decide on your own proposal.

Nothing waits forever. If a node's owners have not answered for a day, Root may decide on it too; the owners can still answer first.

The result. Once every node has an answer, the approved part is merged and the rest is left out: Merged, Partly merged, or Not merged. What was left out comes back to the writer, listed with why. The writer can also merge the approved parts now, leaving the rest out.

How it is built. Each proposal holds one approval per node it changes, with who decided, under which handle, and when. A job checks hourly for approvals waiting more than a day.


Read on

  • A proposal's life: From submission to merged, partly merged or not merged, and what happens after: every stage of a merge proposal.

Under the hood

  • Approvals and pruning: One approval per public node a proposal changes, decided by that node's owners (or Root after a day); what was not approved is pruned and comes back to the writer.

Step by step