Talk and disputes

Public graph

Created about 9 hours ago, updated about 9 hours ago · Owners: Root

ID29562

What it is. Every node has a Talk page. A topic is a discussion, a question or a dispute, and can quote the passage it is about: select text on the node and choose Dispute this… to start one there. Replies are threaded one level deep, and @mentions bring people in.

Resolving. A topic is closed with an outcome: the node was Revised, Kept as it is, Forked, Superseded by another node, or the question was Escalated for a wider decision (for now, to Root). The outcome stays with the topic, so anyone can see how a question was settled.

Who resolves. Whoever opened the topic, the node's author, the node's owners on the public graph, and the owner of a private graph. Anyone who can read the node can take part.

Why it matters. Disagreement is part of how knowledge improves. Talk keeps it next to the node, tied to the exact words in question, instead of in a separate forum.

How it is built. Topics and posts are stored with the node, with the handle each was written under. A node with an open dispute shows a flag in the graph view.

Limits. Moderation tools beyond resolving are In development.


Step by step

  • Open a Talk topic: Discuss a node, ask about it, or dispute a claim in it, on its Talk page.

Part of Working together: talk, messages and notifications and How knowledge improves here: all its parents are equal.

See in the graph Search below

Parents2More general nodes this one belongs to

Children11 node that explain it further